Salt b15 — Mechanism Specificity: Why Jubilee?

This crystal collects adversarial exchanges about why the framework proposes periodic resets (Jubilee) specifically, rather than continuous redistribution, taxation, or other mechanisms.

Status summary: Periodic resets beat continuous taxation under ergodicity constraints (PRO b14). 7TrackRole Markov model supports th9 ergodicity claim (PRO b15). GC analogy conceded but symmetry argument holds (PRO b31).

Related crystals: Salt b11 — Mathematical Foundations and Formalism Status (model status of 7TrackRole), Salt b16 — Wealth Concentration, History, and Voluntariness (historical precedent for mechanism).

Con/Pro Pairs in this Crystal

• Con-C.4 — Gap Between Redistribution Need and Jubilee Specificity
• Pro-E.4 — Response to Con-C.4 (Jubilee Specificity)
• Con-C.5 — th9 Misapplies Ergodicity from Ole Peters’ Framework
• Pro-C.5 — Response to Con-C.5 (th9 Ergodicity)
• Con-D.2.7 — Garbage-Collection Analogy Backfires: Modern GC Moved Away from Stop-the-World
• Pro-E.2.7 — Response to Con-D.2.7 (GC Analogy Backfires)