Alignment Class Echoes — Cross-Model Topic Matches#
Evidence collected during Phase 2I-4 first compilation run (2026-03-25).
Findings#
PET Element |
JUB Element |
Echo Description |
|---|---|---|
ax1 (Containment) |
ax16 (Delegation) |
Both address the God-world relationship structure. ax1 defines containment (world in God); ax16 defines delegation (authority over world granted to humans). Together they establish: world is in God AND humans are authorized agents within it. |
ax5 (Necessary Existence) |
ax15 (Genuine Agency) |
Both are foundational necessity claims in their respective groups. ax5 asserts God necessarily exists; ax15 asserts humans necessarily have genuine agency (performatively self-refuting to deny). Both serve as load-bearing axioms. |
ax8 (Immanent Presence) |
ax17 (Non-Coercive Guidance) |
Both describe how God relates to creation. ax8 says God is present; ax17 says that presence takes the form of guidance, not compulsion. ax17 is the behavioral specification of ax8’s structural claim. |
ax11 (Dipolarity) |
ax22 (Preference for Love) |
Both address divine nature. ax11 defines the dipolar structure (Gn + Gc); ax22 uses that structure to explain why God values freely-chosen care. ax22 is the motivational specification of ax11b_A11bs structural claim. |
Summary#
Four cross-model echoes found. The pattern is consistent: PET axioms establish structural claims about God-world ontology; corresponding JUB axioms specify the behavioral or motivational content within that structure. This suggests the PET→JUB relationship is not merely additive but structurally coupled.