:orphan:

.. include:: /_templates/include-file/page-prefix.rst

.. note:: **Prompt: b14 extraction (v2) --- rewritten 2026m04d06.**
   Incorporates all b12/b13 extraction lessons AND the b18 Call to Action
   arc-awareness layer. Replaces ``b14-prompt-extraction.rst``.


****************************************************************************************************
Prompt: b14-extraction (v2) --- JUB Knowledge Base Extraction
****************************************************************************************************

| **VVN:** ``dv_ClaOp46_v2_2026m04d06`` (replaces v1: ``b14-prompt-extraction.rst``)
| **Series:** HEAVEN prompt rewrite (b18 Call to Action as North Star)

Arc Position
=============

**b14 (JUB) is the economic engine of the HEAVEN series.** It answers
the question that every practical person will ask after reading b11--b13:
"This is all very nice, but how does it *work* in the real world? How
do you actually build an economy that self-corrects?"

**What b14 must accomplish for the Call to Action (b18):**

The Call to Action will ask humanity to shift from MAD (Mutually Assured
Destruction) to MAP (Mutually Assured Progress). That shift requires a
credible economic alternative to the current system. b14 provides it:
the Jubilee System, formally derived from axioms, showing how periodic
recalibration prevents concentration of power from reaching the OSCR
tipping point. Without b14, the Call to Action is aspiration without
mechanism.

**Extraction focus:** While extracting, pay special attention to
material that:

1. Explains the Prisoner's Dilemma → Assurance Game transition
   (connects to b13 th6, the Commitment Trichotomy)
2. Addresses "why Jubilee and not socialism/capitalism/other?" (the
   strongest objection from economists)
3. Contains real-world analogies for the Jubilee mechanism (examples
   that b18 can use)
4. Addresses the "free rider" problem (the game-theoretic objection)
5. Contains any material about existential risk or nuclear winter
   (feeds b16 and b18)

**New extraction category for b14:**

In addition to categories A--H from the original prompt, add:

**I. CALL-TO-ACTION MATERIAL** --- Anything discovered during extraction
that the Call to Action (b18) should reference: vivid analogies,
surprising results, formulations that a 12-year-old could understand,
one-sentence summaries of key results, potential "Monday morning" actions.


The Core Extraction Task
==========================

Everything below is the same as the original b14-prompt-extraction.rst
with the following additions:

1. **Add category I (Call-to-Action Material)** to the extraction
   categories.

2. **In Phase 3 (Build the KB), add a section: "Steelmanning for b14
   Paper."** For each axiom group and each theorem, note:

   - The strongest objection a skeptic would raise
   - The strongest objection a person with vested interests would raise
     (bankers for ax25 Jubilee, libertarians for ax16 Delegation,
     determinists for ax15 Agency, theologians for th5 Divine
     Non-Responsibility)
   - Whether the JUB development logs contain responses to these
     objections (and where)

3. **In the "Notes for Other Papers" section, add a dedicated
   "Notes for b18 (Call to Action)" subsection.** Collect:

   - The single best analogy for the Jubilee mechanism found in the logs
   - The single most surprising result from the JUB development
   - Any passage that connects JUB to nuclear risk or existential threat
   - The "elevator pitch" for JUB in 2 sentences

4. **In Phase 4 (Retrospective), add question 9:**

   9. Did the Call-to-Action extraction (category I) yield material that
      would work in a speech addressed to all of humanity? What register
      was it in (academic / conversational / urgent / inspirational)?
      What register does b18 need?


Execution
==========

Follow the original b14-prompt-extraction.rst for all other details:
file paths, phase structure, scope rules, split protocol, build check.

The original prompt is at:
``source/matheology/hell/ll/study/b/14/b14-prompt-extraction.rst``

Read it first, then apply the additions above.