.. meta::
   :description: AI overview of the 66-page near-tenure dossier submitted to UW-Madison — "Breaking Strangleholds on Interdisciplinary Innovation" — proposing a Department for Interdisciplinary Research (DIR) at the Wisconsin Institute for Discovery.
   :keywords: tenure dossier, WID, Wisconsin Institute for Discovery, interdisciplinary research, DIR, Department for Interdisciplinary Research, Conway's Law, batching strategies, academic freedom, Evolvix, Loewe, UW-Madison, MMv3
   :og:card:title: Near-Tenure Dossier<br>66 pages — UW-Madison
   :og:card:description: 66-page near-tenure dossier — "Breaking Strangleholds on Interdisciplinary Innovation" — proposing DIR at WID to protect interdisciplinary research.

.. include:: /_templates/include-file/page-prefix.rst


.. title:: Near-Tenure Dossier


****************************************************************************************************
Near-Tenure Dossier — Breaking Strangleholds on Interdisciplinary Innovation
****************************************************************************************************

*"1 simple big idea in 3 points" — a 66-page analysis of why interdisciplinary research centers need tenure rights and a Department for Interdisciplinary Research.*


.. admonition:: Download the original document (PDF)
   :class: note

   .. warning::
      Large file: 8.4 MB PDF

   `Near-Tenure Dossier — PDF (8.4 MB) </_file/pdf/gnp/mmv3/dusty-deep-data/loewe-about-me-science/loewe-2018m10d09-near-tenure-dossier-main-part-last-submit-to-uw-madison-exhibit-d-66page.pdf>`__
   — 66 pages, :doc:`Jonah License with CC0 Public Domain </license/joli/index>`

   Filename: ``loewe-2018m10d09-near-tenure-dossier-main-part-last-submit-to-uw-madison-exhibit-d-66page.pdf``

   `WebP preview (116 KB) </_file/pdf/gnp/mmv3/dusty-deep-data/loewe-about-me-science/loewe-2018m10d09-near-tenure-dossier-main-part-last-submit-to-uw-madison-exhibit-d-66page.webp>`__

   Also in this folder: :doc:`NSF CAREER Grant <loewe-2011-nsf-grant>`,
   :doc:`LLoL Resume <loewe-resume>`


.. image:: /_file/pdf/gnp/mmv3/dusty-deep-data/loewe-about-me-science/loewe-2018m10d09-near-tenure-dossier-main-part-last-submit-to-uw-madison-exhibit-d-66page.webp
   :alt: Near-Tenure Dossier — Breaking Strangleholds on Interdisciplinary Innovation
   :width: 100%
   :align: center


|


--- Overview AI-generated by dv_ClaOp46Max_ExhF_2026m04d16 ---Start---


Abstract
========

A 66-page document titled **"Breaking Strangleholds on Interdisciplinary
Innovation — 1 simple big idea in 3 points,"** written as a letter to
Jo Handelsman (Director of the Wisconsin Institute for Discovery), CC'd
to Millard Susman and John Yin. Dated 2018m09d21 (WID, Madison), with
minor updates and expanded conclusions on 2018m10d08. Subtitled "Letter
to Jo — New Perspectives Summarized — Snapshot of a paused tenure
dossier evolution."

The document frames Loewe's tenure process not as a personal case but
as a systemic analysis of **why interdisciplinary research centers
struggle** within the departmental structure of modern universities.
The "1 simple big idea" is:

**Point 1:** WID cannot accomplish its core interdisciplinary research
mission efficiently without the ability to grant tenure. Without tenure
rights, WID researchers are "conceptually limited and in practice left
to the mercy of disciplinary departments."

**Point 2:** WID cannot grant tenure without a new department.
Conventional ideas crown winning disciplines and hurt others. Only one
idea is different: create a **Department for Interdisciplinary Research
(DIR)** that focuses on the meta-research needed to improve the
efficiency of interdisciplinary research itself.

**Point 3:** Starting a DIR in WID is workable, timely, and improves
efficiency. WID in its present state is an ideal springboard for a DIR.

The document includes 6 appendices: practical questions (Appendix 0),
WID stability analysis (Appendix 1), why WID needs tenure (Appendix 2),
departments that would limit diversity (Appendix 3), credibility and
reasonability in interdisciplinary context (Appendix 4), and a legacy
table of contents for the tenure dossier front matter (Appendix 5).
Attachments include incomplete draft tenure dossier overview statements,
output diversity discussion using the "Evolvix Giants of Biodata
Science" document, posters, and a recent CV.


Broader Significance (Claude's Assessment)
============================================

1. **Systemic analysis, not just a tenure case.** The document transcends
   personal grievance to analyze a structural problem: Conway's Law
   ("organizations which design systems are constrained to produce
   designs which are copies of the communication structures of these
   organizations") applied to universities. The insight that
   departmental "batching strategies" systematically limit
   interdisciplinary innovation is broadly applicable.

2. **The DIR concept anticipates later LLoL themes.** The proposal for
   a Department for Interdisciplinary Research — meta-research about
   how to make interdisciplinary research more efficient — is an
   early form of the self-stabilizing innovation framework that later
   became central to the Matheo papers and the Epiocracy concept.

3. **Metrics critique.** The document's analysis of academic metrics
   ("Not everything that matters can be measured and not everything
   that can be measured matters" — Einstein) and the argument that
   academic freedom is "effectively limited to the equivalents of
   after-work hours or overtime" foreshadows the broader critique
   of institutional self-destruction patterns in the BABL framework.

4. **Personal stakes made explicit.** The "stark choice" passage (p.12)
   — either build on genetics results in WID or stay in WID by
   pleasing the home department — documents the institutional
   dynamics that eventually led to Loewe leaving academia and
   founding the LLoL project.

5. **Historical record of WID dynamics.** The document provides
   a rare first-person account of institutional challenges at a
   major interdisciplinary research center, including observations
   about "natural no-go zones" between departments, the "quant-bio
   divide," and the paradox that WID's interdisciplinary mission
   was structurally undermined by its lack of tenure rights.


Key Concepts at a Glance
==========================

.. list-table::
   :widths: 30 70
   :header-rows: 0

   * - **DIR (Department for Interdisciplinary Research)**
     - Proposed new department at WID focusing on meta-research to
       improve the efficiency of interdisciplinary research itself
   * - **Conway's Law**
     - Organizations produce designs that mirror their communication
       structures — applied to show how departmental silos limit
       interdisciplinary innovation
   * - **Batching strategies**
     - How departments organize work; conflicts between departmental
       and interdisciplinary batching strategies are the root cause
       of the innovation stranglehold
   * - **Natural no-go zones**
     - Areas of expertise that fall between departmental boundaries,
       conceptually existing but unsupported by any department
   * - **WID (Wisconsin Institute for Discovery)**
     - UW-Madison's interdisciplinary research center, described as
       "a Great Wisconsin Experiment" — Loewe was its first external
       faculty hire
   * - **Hot streaks**
     - Research is most productive in career "hot streaks"; without
       DIR-like support, the initial stages of discovery required
       for nurturing hot streaks are discriminated against
   * - **Evolvix mission**
     - "Simplify accurate modeling of systems described in a stable
       extensible user-friendly language" — the research vision that
       required crossing departmental boundaries


Document Information
=====================

.. list-table::
   :widths: 30 70
   :header-rows: 0

   * - **Document ID**
     - Exhibit D (About-Me Science, Dusty Deep Data)
   * - **Full title**
     - Breaking Strangleholds on Interdisciplinary Innovation —
       1 simple big idea in 3 points
   * - **Author**
     - Laurence "Lion" Loewe
   * - **Date**
     - 2018m09d21 (letter); 2018m10d08 (updates); 2018m10d09
       (last submission to UW-Madison)
   * - **To**
     - Jo Handelsman, Wisconsin Institute for Discovery
   * - **CC**
     - Millard Susman, John Yin
   * - **Format**
     - 66-page letter with 6 appendices + 4 attachments (draft tenure
       statements, output diversity discussion, posters, CV)
   * - **License**
     - :doc:`Jonah License with CC0 Public Domain </license/joli/index>`
   * - **Part of**
     - Good News Pack MMv3, Dusty Deep Data / About-Me Science
   * - **PDF size**
     - 8.4 MB
   * - **WebP size**
     - 116 KB

Related documents in the Good News Pack:

- :doc:`NSF CAREER Grant <loewe-2011-nsf-grant>` (the grant that established the research program documented here)
- :doc:`LLoL Resume & CV <loewe-resume>` (the current career overview, including post-WID trajectory)
- :doc:`Teaching Syllabus <loewe-2018-teaching-syllabus>` (the course that emerged from the same period)


--- Overview AI-generated by dv_ClaOp46Max_ExhF_2026m04d16 ---End---


.. ----- FOOTER FORM dv_ClaOp46Max_ExhF ----- type open-std ----- START -----

.. |content-vvn| replace:: dv_ClaOp46Max_ExhF_2026m04d16

.. include:: /_templates/include-file/footer/separator/tidal-gradient.rst

.. dropdown:: Notes
   :class-container: page-footer-form-notes
   :class-title: page-footer-form-title

   .. include:: /_templates/include-file/footer/page-footer-stability.rst


.. only:: html

   .. include:: /_templates/include-file/footer/cta/gnp-mmv3-review.rst

   .. dropdown:: FF FeedbackFlow to improve this page: How you can contribute
      :class-container: page-footer-form-feedbackflow
      :class-title: page-footer-form-title

      .. include:: /_templates/include-file/footer/form-open-std/prelink.rst

      .. ----- PAGE-SPECIFIC FF (ff-email MailForm=OOv2r0p0) ----- START -----

      .. raw:: html

         <a class="ff-email-preview-link" href="mailto:FF+mmv3-ddd-about-me-science-tenure-dossier@balospe.com?cc=FF%2BCompleteFeedbackFlow%40balospe.com&amp;subject=FF%20k2%20s2%20AIMS%20for%20%5Bmmv3-ddd-about-me-science-tenure-dossier%5D%20Replace_by_OneLineSummary_of_proposed_FF_improvement&amp;body=To%20make%20this%20page%20%5Bmmv3-ddd-about-me-science-tenure-dossier%5D%0D%0Amore%20gentle%20kind%20reasonable%0D%0Afor%20beginners%2C%20producers%2C%20andOr%20experts%0D%0Awith%20a%20background%20in%20xyz%3A%0D%0A%0D%0APlease%20consider%20improving%20this%3A%0D%0A%0D%0A%0D%0A--%0D%0ABy%20sending%20this%20email%2C%20I%20agree%20that%20its%20content%20may%20be%20published%0D%0Aunder%20the%20Jonah%20License%20(balospe.com%2Fen%2Flicense%2Fjoli%2F)%0D%0Aunless%20I%20state%20otherwise%20above.%20MailForm%3DOOv2r0p0">To:      FF+mmv3-ddd-about-me-science-tenure-dossier@balospe.com
         CC:      FF+CompleteFeedbackFlow@balospe.com
         Subject: FF k2 s2 AIMS for [mmv3-ddd-about-me-science-tenure-dossier] Replace_by_OneLineSummary
         Body:    To make this page [mmv3-ddd-about-me-science-tenure-dossier]
                  more gentle kind reasonable
                  for beginners, producers, andOr experts
                  with a background in xyz:

                  Please consider improving this:

                  --
                  By sending this email, I agree that its content may be published
                  under the Jonah License (balospe.com/en/license/joli/)
                  unless I state otherwise above. MailForm=OOv2r0p0</a>

      .. ----- PAGE-SPECIFIC FF ----- END -----

      .. include:: /_templates/include-file/footer/form-open-std/postlink.rst


.. ----- FOOTER FORM dv_ClaOp46Max_ExhF ----- END -----